What would you do with 6.3 acres of open space?

The Open Space Commission debates what to do with the township owned property known as 'The Rock.'


Sign up for the West Orange Patch Newsletter by clicking here.

Like the West Orange Patch on Facebook by clicking here.

While open space is usually hard to come by, the township has lately had the opposite problem: deciding what to do with it.

For the second time in a month, the topic of how best to maximize the township’s open space has come up. On Monday, the Open Space Commission met to bounce around ideas about what to do with a 6.3 acres of land at the top of Mt. Pleasant Avenue known as “The Rock.”

While many ideas were discussed and debated at the meeting, everyone on the commission seemed to agree about three fundamental things:

  • The property should be open to the public;
  • Whatever is build should have a minimal impact on the surrounding environment; and
  • The schools should be involved in someway. 

“We are open to anything,” said Chairman of the OSC Joseph McCartney.

Some of the ideas suggested at the meeting included: planting an orchard; planting a community garden; planting a tree nursery; making it a recreation area; allowing the land to be regrown naturally; having simply an open field; using it as out-door classrooms for the schools; and putting in walking paths. 

However, the commission realized that every suggestion had to be measured by three limitations: 

  • There is little room for parking; 
  • The land is located at a dangerous curve at the top of Mt. Pleasant, causing ingress and egress problems; and
  • The wildlife in the area. 

“We had a lot of ideas when we started this,” said Bill Sullivan at the meeting, “but once you reach the conclusion that whatever it is can’t be used in which there are more than five or 10 cars maximum at one time, that really narrows down the potential uses of the property.” 

Leigh Ann Zaolino, a resident whose own property is adjacent to “The Rock,” came prepared to the meeting with pictures of the area and advice for the commission. 

She informed the commission that whatever was to be done with the property, it needed to be “low-impact" in order to preserve the the turkeys, hawks, and other wildlife occupying the land  

And Zaolino brought up a problem that the commission had not thought of: a garden would be like giving the wildlife in the area a free ticket to an all you can eat buffet. 

“If you put a garden there,” said Zaolino, “you will have to find a way to keep the deer, the fox, the rabbit, the turkeys, and everything else that is in there [out]. You might as well just open it up and call it Whole Foods for the turkeys and everything else. 

“You are going to just bring more wildlife and strange wildlife to the area, and piss off the gardeners because they are going to be taking their stuff.”

Of all the wildlife in the area, Township Forester John Linson said that deer will be the biggest problem.

“I feel that the deer are the only real impediment,” said Linson, because they over graze and destroy the understory vegetation, leaving nothing for any other native species to adequately survive. Fencing, he suggested, would be one potential way to prevent deer from destroying the habitat. 

“It’s a very sensitive site,” said Linson. “We want to reestablish vegetation. The only way we are going to reestablish vegetation is to exclude deer, and ... turkeys and rabbits and squirrels and hawks.” 

The property at 577 Mt. Pleasant Ave., across from the Environmental Center, was purchased by the township in August 2011 in an effort to curb development on the site. The property has sat vacant for years as many proposals to build something there have come and gone. 

However, there was infrastructure construction done to the property in anticipation of some of the projects, such as an assisted living home, so as a result nearly all utilities and proper runoff pipes have been installed. 

There is still a dilapidated home on the property, but the township is now seeking bids to have it taken down, said Assistant Director of Public Works Nick Salese, who was at the meeting on Monday. 

In addition, Linson added that whatever the township decides to do, one of the biggest problems is the fact that the property is practically barren. 

“Basically it is like a strip-mine site; all of the valuable soil has been removed,” said Linson. 

The Public Works Department will soon be adding about 2,000 cubic yards of soil to the site, but more will be necessary to fully cover “The Rock.” The goal, said Salese, is to add about 12 to 16 inches of dirt to the site, and then another 4 inches of top soil. 

The commission tentatively scheduled a public meeting on October 15 to hear suggestions from the public on what to do with the site. A location and a meeting time have yet to be announced.

The OSC will then make its recommendation to the township council about what to do with the site. The township council will ultimately have the final vote on what will be done with “The Rock.” 


jackie oliver July 10, 2012 at 11:41 AM
my opinion.... leave it as an open space for people to enjoy. once an open space is gone, it is gone. one of the beautiful things i remember about growing up and living and working in WO was just that....open spaces.
Pam July 10, 2012 at 11:50 AM
I agree. Leave it as a natural, undeveloped open space.
Leigh-Ann Zaolino July 10, 2012 at 01:00 PM
Why does everything have to be developed in this town? Leave the property alone and let mother nature have it. The purpose of open space is just that...
Gary Van Wyk July 10, 2012 at 01:43 PM
Drill for oil.
Ann Aly Ahmed July 10, 2012 at 01:52 PM
I agree that the space should be left an "OPEN" space for nature and wildlife. We have taken so much away from the wildlife in this area, it would be nice to know they is one area not touched.
barry_geltzeiler July 10, 2012 at 02:51 PM
Dump the dirt and top soil and close it off. give it back to the wild life. let it grow wildly and the animals enjoy.
Kelly Wenzel July 10, 2012 at 05:52 PM
I could not make the meeting on Monday night. I am glad to see that parking and safety came up in the meeting because that was my concern. Being on the bend like that with no sidewalks makes it inaccessible by walking and parking would be awkward if it were turned into a community garden. Question: Why bother spend the time and money to put down topsoil at this point if there is no tangible plan? Perhaps you should have an open house at the location, so people can see the area and come up with ideas on the spot. As a resident who lives on the same hill as this property, and as a Naturalist by profession, I can tell you that gardening on bedrock is nearly impossible... I don't care how much soil you put down. It will become a maintenance nightmare and cause erosion on the hill. Leaving it an open, mountain-top 'park' might be great... our very own "Hawk Look-out"!
Leigh-Ann Zaolino July 11, 2012 at 12:52 AM
There is an abundance of wild turkey's on the parcel, deer, rabbits, a fox, the Hawks, and cats. The entire purpose of the town purchasing the land was to prevent from being developed. Any discussion to the contrary makes no logical sense. Kelly is correct, planting is a nightmare on this rock, if you don't use berms you need to blast to dig. The volume of traffic at this site is intense due to the recycling center. It is not uncommon for over 100 trucks a day to enter the site dropping off or picking up mulch and top soil... then add in the residents who go daily. Pulling in or out of the recycling center is difficult can you imagine pulling out onto that stretch of roadway right at that bend by Summit? My driveway is 100' from the bend and I have to pray I don't get hit every day! Open space is just that... open space. Leave the site alone and let the animals have it.
Leigh-Ann Zaolino July 11, 2012 at 12:54 AM
Next Open Space meeting is October 15th - mark your calendars... I also posted some pictures of the "dangerous curve" noted in the article.
Kevin July 11, 2012 at 04:10 PM
I don't see any reason to spend a penny on this property right now. Let it be natural "open space" that is simply not developed. Maybe in the future, we could do something with it. On a related note...I'd love to see a community garden somewhere that makes sense. Even if it was a small one, in multiple locations. Great education for the kids in town also.
Jim July 12, 2012 at 12:34 AM
I'd use tax dollars to build a really expensive restaurant. Oh wait....
Leigh-Ann Zaolino July 12, 2012 at 02:14 AM
An INFORMED comment would be appreciated. What part of you can not BUILD on this site don't some get? Government funds were used to purchase the land for OPEN SPACE... The contract for the purchase using this funding source is clear and simple. Open space means just that - zero density for a business or for profit. The only question on the table is should the 6.3 parcel be replanted because it was stripped by the developer who went bankrupt and how. The access to the site is geographically dangerous for ingress/egress. Any usage of the parcel that is not low density is a traffic problem.
Leigh-Ann Zaolino July 12, 2012 at 02:16 AM
While a "community garden" sounds lovely, the high volume of wild life makes it impossible and impractical to consider. The cost to fence the property from wildlife is not cost effective. Our tax dollars could be better utilized elsewhere.
Bob DeVos July 27, 2012 at 05:33 PM
Leave it as open space, let the animals have it. You've been taking away all their other spaces. That's a cost effective option, don't do anything!
hongfeng December 28, 2012 at 01:25 AM
http://www.coachoutletonlinebfd.com/ Coach Outlet Online http://www.guccibeltstb.com/ Gucci Belt http://www.coachoutletonlineyds.net/ Coach Outlet Store Online http://www.cocoachoutletonline.org/ Coach Outlet Online http://www.coachoutletonlinetsy.net/ Coach Online Outlet


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something